Death Row Wedding
Second in a two-part series
This article was published on Saturday, December 22, 2007 9:10 PM CST in Columns
By John Brummett
THE MORNING NEWS
Women in a book club in Little Rock were talking about what they might read next. One suggested Mara Leveritt's "Devil's Knot" because Damien Echols and that West Memphis case fascinated her.
There was an odd quiet.
Later, during kitchen cleanup, someone mentioned to the woman who had made the suggestion that one of their club members, that perfectly charming Lorri Davis, the landscape architect from New York City, was Damien Echols' wife.
You just don't tend to think that the woman next to you at the book club is married to a convicted child murderer.
You cannot begin to tell Echols' story without mentioning his wife of eight years, even as the woman clings tenaciously to a low profile.
"She doesn't want to become a freak show, the crazy woman married to a Death Row inmate," Echols told me in a two-hour interview on that very Death Row last week.
Davis was living in New York City in 1995 when she got invited to an art house for an advance showing of "Paradise Lost." That's the HBO documentary about the hysteria in West Memphis over that supposed satanic ritual that led to Echols and two other outcast teenagers getting convicted in the torture and killing of three little boys in 1993.
The story moved her. She wrote Echols and enclosed a red thread she'd found on a New York City sidewalk, calling it a symbol of human connection.
Echols had been on Death Row for more than a year. He said he'd given up and was ready to die. But he said he knew instantly that this woman was communicating with him "in a way that was totally new to me -- that I'd been searching for."
He wrote back. She responded. Then she wrote that she was coming to see him.
"I was in love with her already," he said. Was he nervous? "Scared to death."
She moved to Little Rock and began coming to see him every week, visiting through this very kind of glass.
"We couldn't touch," he said. "We'd each pull a hair out and give it to each other. We'd lean down to the screen and blow, to share our breath."
After four years of touchless courtship, "I'm pretty sure we had the only Buddhist wedding ceremony in the history of Arkansas Death Row," he said.
This political movement to get him freed, all this legal research, this public relations campaign, all these celebrities who have come to Echols' aid -- Lorri Davis has done that.
"These have been the happiest 12 years of my life," Echols said.
When I burst out laughing at the very idea of Death Row being better than childhood, he laughed, too.
Echols has a son, 14-year-old Seth, by a teenage girlfriend. The boy lives in Arizona and comes to visit maybe once a year.
Echols told me: "When he was 10 or 11, he was into rap and he said, 'I'm a pimp.' I said, 'No, you're not. If I'd wanted a black child, I'd have adopted one from Africa. Pull your pants up and quit talking like that.' I don't want him turning out like me."
Did he mean that he didn't want his kid winding up on Death Row on a highly controversial conviction?
"No, I don't want him to be a dropout, considered weird by his style and taste in music (Metallica, in Echols' case)," he said.
What if a governor commuted his death sentence to life in prison?
"That would be worse than meaningless," Echols said. "If you're going to do that, just kill me now instead of doing it slowly."
Echols seems uncommonly bright. He is remarkably self-educated. He is thoughtful, if, at times, still a bit of the smart-aleck. He is strikingly articulate, save his one "I had saw" comment.
Is it possible that Echols was such a bizarre creature at 18 that he committed this crime? Yes, I guess it's possible. But the authorities didn't make the case. And there was a mad rush to frenzied, predisposed judgment.
The thought never occurred to me over a two-hour interview that I was inches from a child murderer. I wanted to shake his hand upon leaving, but, of course, couldn't.
John Brummett is a columnist and reporter for Stephens Media in Little Rock.
Sunday, December 23, 2007
Saturday, December 22, 2007
Echols' Pursuit of "Magic" by John Brummett
Echols' Pursuit Of 'Magic'
This article was published on Friday, December 21, 2007 6:27 PM CST in Columns
By John Brummett
THE MORNING NEWS
Editor's Note: This is first of a two-part series. The second part will be published Sunday.
The first thing that strikes you about Damien Echols is his hollow, pale, frail appearance.
That hair, much shorter now than when he got convicted of capital murder 14 years ago at age 19, remains jet black. His big, darting eyes are nearly as dark.
That provides a striking contrast against Echols' alarmingly washed-out complexion.
He's all skin and bones, especially in the sparse and chiseled face that was so round and fat in those news videotapes from 1993.
"I haven't seen the sun in five years," he says in an East Arkansas drawl from the other side of the glass, where the Death Row guard at the Varner Unit has just deposited him.
This is for what will be a two-hour interview. I am here because there's a new burst of activity from well-meaning people trying to build public sentiment in his behalf.
We will cover spirituality, love and marriage, art, literature, politics and, above all, the pursuit of "magic."
No, not black magic. It may well have been Echols' tragic lot to be misunderstood. It becomes apparent that, by magic, he refers to grandly ambitious pursuits of creativity and learning in search of a higher meaning, or God, within himself.
From Death Row, he became an ordained Buddhist. But he likes Catholicism and says he never misses mass. He has maintained that fateful childhood interest in Wicca, a religion extolling nature and the supernatural, and which, let us stress, isn't Satanism. He embraces none of those exclusively, but applies all generally, he says, to seek "divinity through discipline."
He writes not-bad poetry. He wrote an autobiography. He writes songs. He reads books, thousands of them. He has a wish list at amazon.com. People have sent so many books he has to have them stored in a mini-warehouse. He draws. He does yoga. He meditates. For a while, he ran in place for more than two hours at a time, until his feet bled.
If he gets out of prison, he plans to learn first-aid, ballroom dancing and "every swim stroke imaginable," just for starters. His goal is to live large, not live dead, as he believes so many in his family and childhood circle lived.
He says his father stared into the distance over morning coffee as Damien's mom begged him to communicate. Then dad disappeared for 10 years.
Echols was a bright, troubled, disadvantaged, rebellious and irreverent kid in West Memphis who dropped out of high school but frequented the public library. He cut an eerie image in an old black trench coat that he found in the closet of an ancient house.
Even now, more pensive but still given to calling people "bleeping morons," he sees clothes as an expression. If he gets out of prison, he says, he'll look for leather pants and silk shirts.
"I mean, if you're going to just wear jeans and a ball cap, I don't see the point in getting dressed at all," he says.
Like all Death Row inmates, Echols is permitted to go to a caged, roofed, concrete-floored "yard" five hours a week. But he declines. He says the sun can't get through anyway. He says there are too many pigeon droppings out there. He says mosquitoes nearly carried him off.
Echols says he weighs 145 pounds, down about 60 pounds from his paunchy state when charged with and convicted with two other outcast teenagers of torturing and killing three little boys in what police called a Satanic act.
"It's partly bad health," he says of the weight loss. He's arthritic and his eyesight is failing.
"But part of it is what I ate back then," he says. "It was chocolate cereal with sugar for breakfast, pizza for lunch and a hamburger for dinner."
Tomorrow: Though he aches to get out of prison, Echols says his last 12 years, all on Death Row, have been the best of his life, far better than his miserable childhood. It's because of a woman.
John Brummett is a columnist for the Arkansas News Bureau in Little Rock. His e-mail address is jbrummett@arkansasnews.com; his telephone number is (501) 374-0699.
About this columnist: John Brummett has been writing about Arkansas and national politics for three decades and as a regular columnist since 1986. Last year he won first place in commentary writing from the national Association of Capitol Reporters and Editors. This year he took second place in humorous commentary in an 11-state Southern competition sponsored by the Society of Professional Journalists. Email Brummett at jbrummett@arkansasnews.com. Check out Brummett's blog for the latest in Arkansas political news.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This article was published on Friday, December 21, 2007 6:27 PM CST in Columns
By John Brummett
THE MORNING NEWS
Editor's Note: This is first of a two-part series. The second part will be published Sunday.
The first thing that strikes you about Damien Echols is his hollow, pale, frail appearance.
That hair, much shorter now than when he got convicted of capital murder 14 years ago at age 19, remains jet black. His big, darting eyes are nearly as dark.
That provides a striking contrast against Echols' alarmingly washed-out complexion.
He's all skin and bones, especially in the sparse and chiseled face that was so round and fat in those news videotapes from 1993.
"I haven't seen the sun in five years," he says in an East Arkansas drawl from the other side of the glass, where the Death Row guard at the Varner Unit has just deposited him.
This is for what will be a two-hour interview. I am here because there's a new burst of activity from well-meaning people trying to build public sentiment in his behalf.
We will cover spirituality, love and marriage, art, literature, politics and, above all, the pursuit of "magic."
No, not black magic. It may well have been Echols' tragic lot to be misunderstood. It becomes apparent that, by magic, he refers to grandly ambitious pursuits of creativity and learning in search of a higher meaning, or God, within himself.
From Death Row, he became an ordained Buddhist. But he likes Catholicism and says he never misses mass. He has maintained that fateful childhood interest in Wicca, a religion extolling nature and the supernatural, and which, let us stress, isn't Satanism. He embraces none of those exclusively, but applies all generally, he says, to seek "divinity through discipline."
He writes not-bad poetry. He wrote an autobiography. He writes songs. He reads books, thousands of them. He has a wish list at amazon.com. People have sent so many books he has to have them stored in a mini-warehouse. He draws. He does yoga. He meditates. For a while, he ran in place for more than two hours at a time, until his feet bled.
If he gets out of prison, he plans to learn first-aid, ballroom dancing and "every swim stroke imaginable," just for starters. His goal is to live large, not live dead, as he believes so many in his family and childhood circle lived.
He says his father stared into the distance over morning coffee as Damien's mom begged him to communicate. Then dad disappeared for 10 years.
Echols was a bright, troubled, disadvantaged, rebellious and irreverent kid in West Memphis who dropped out of high school but frequented the public library. He cut an eerie image in an old black trench coat that he found in the closet of an ancient house.
Even now, more pensive but still given to calling people "bleeping morons," he sees clothes as an expression. If he gets out of prison, he says, he'll look for leather pants and silk shirts.
"I mean, if you're going to just wear jeans and a ball cap, I don't see the point in getting dressed at all," he says.
Like all Death Row inmates, Echols is permitted to go to a caged, roofed, concrete-floored "yard" five hours a week. But he declines. He says the sun can't get through anyway. He says there are too many pigeon droppings out there. He says mosquitoes nearly carried him off.
Echols says he weighs 145 pounds, down about 60 pounds from his paunchy state when charged with and convicted with two other outcast teenagers of torturing and killing three little boys in what police called a Satanic act.
"It's partly bad health," he says of the weight loss. He's arthritic and his eyesight is failing.
"But part of it is what I ate back then," he says. "It was chocolate cereal with sugar for breakfast, pizza for lunch and a hamburger for dinner."
Tomorrow: Though he aches to get out of prison, Echols says his last 12 years, all on Death Row, have been the best of his life, far better than his miserable childhood. It's because of a woman.
John Brummett is a columnist for the Arkansas News Bureau in Little Rock. His e-mail address is jbrummett@arkansasnews.com; his telephone number is (501) 374-0699.
About this columnist: John Brummett has been writing about Arkansas and national politics for three decades and as a regular columnist since 1986. Last year he won first place in commentary writing from the national Association of Capitol Reporters and Editors. This year he took second place in humorous commentary in an 11-state Southern competition sponsored by the Society of Professional Journalists. Email Brummett at jbrummett@arkansasnews.com. Check out Brummett's blog for the latest in Arkansas political news.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thursday, December 20, 2007
Natalie Maines joins LR protest for imprisoned 3
Picture courtesy of Free the West Memphis Three myspace
Natalie Maines joins LR protest for imprisoned 3
BY CATHY FRYE
Posted on Thursday, December 20, 2007
Email this story | Printer-friendly version
The voice of Natalie Maines, lead singer for the Dixie Chicks, floated across the state Capitol grounds Wednesday as a line of “West Memphis Three” supporters snaked up the steps with a giant banner.
Maines was due to arrive any minute. Meanwhile, those rallying for the release of three men convicted in the 1993 slayings of three 8-year-old boys listened to a recording of the Dixie Chicks’ 2006 hit, Not Ready to Make Nice Forgive, sounds good Forget, I’m not sure I could They say time heals everything But I’m still waiting...
About 150 people — including national media and an HBO film crew — attended the rally. Coordinators of Take Action Arkansas presented the governor’s office with hundreds of letters asking that Gov. Mike Beebe and Attorney General Dustin McDaniel review the 1994 murder convictions of Damien Echols, Jason Baldwin and Jessie Misskelley.
Echols, Baldwin and Misskelley — now known as the West Memphis Three — were teenagers at the time of the killings. Echols was sentenced to death; Baldwin and Misskelley are serving life sentences.
The victims were three 8-year-old boys: Chris Byers, Stevie Branch and Michael Moore. Police and prosecutors say they were killed during a satanic ritual, pointing to the boys’ wounds, particularly the genital mutilation of Chris Byers.
Last month, however, a defense team filed a writ of habeas corpus, arguing that new DNA and forensic testing hasn’t yet linked any of the three men to the crime scene. Rather, the defense says hair and fiber evidence suggest the presence of Terry Hobbs, stepfather of Stevie. Six scientists who recently reviewed the evidence say the boys’ wounds and Chris’ mutilation were caused by animals preying on the bodies after the children were killed.
Realizing that the filing had renewed interest in the case — which in the past has resonated primarily with celebrities and out-of-state organizations — Little Rock restaurateur Capi Peck decided to seek support from Arkansans.
In recent weeks, with the help of Echols’ wife, Lorri Davis, Peck organized a letter-writing campaign and petition drive. On Wednesday, Maines arrived in town to speak at the group’s first rally.
Around noon, after 60 to 70 people lined up on the Capitol steps with a banner made from hundreds of postcards demanding the release of the West Memphis Three, the singer addressed a cheering crowd.
“I’m just amazed that these guys are still in prison and that they turned into men in prison,” she said, explaining why she had decided to offer her support and a donation to the group’s defense team.
Too many questions have arisen since the men were convicted, she said. “When you’re putting someone to death, you have to be 100 percent sure.” The recent DNA and forensic results, she said, have “given this case wings.” Davis, who married the imprisoned Echols in 1999, also spoke briefly. Dressed in a tailored brown dress, she nervously approached the podium and thanked supporters for their efforts and donations over the years.
Davis urged the crowd to read about the new science being applied to the case. “It is real. It proves the innocence of these three men. It’s time that Arkansas did take action.” Wednesday’s crowd was diverse, made up of elderly women in sensible shoes, teenagers dressed in black, and men and women in business attire.
Lauren Spencer, 25, of Little Rock said she’s followed the case for years, always believing the trial was a travesty of justice.
“From the very beginning it was ridiculous that they were convicted,” she said. “Now there’s more evidence showing they didn’t do it. It’s icing on the cake.” The rally ended with Maines, Davis and Peck taking about 1, 000 letters to the governor’s office.
Beebe wasn’t there, spokesman Matt DeCample said, but he and several other representatives accepted the bundles.
“They stayed, and we talked for about 10 to 15 minutes,” he said. “They had some questions about the process.” Beebe said Tuesday that he has no intention of intervening in the case while it’s still winding its way through the courts.
Peck said she expected that response, saying the group understands the role of the judicial process. “Our hope is to expedite things,” she said.
Wednesday, December 19, 2007
Media Alert
Rally at the Arkansas Capitol Wednesday Will Urge Governor and Attorney General to Help Free the ‘West Memphis Three’
Community leaders, supporters and Dixie Chicks’ Natalie Maines will speak and deliver hundreds of letters and petitions asking elected officials to review the overwhelming evidence of innocence and help secure justice
(LITTLE ROCK, AR; December 17, 2007) – In an unprecedented statement of community support for the men who were wrongfully convicted of murdering three West Memphis boys in 1993, local leaders and community members will deliver hundreds of letters and petitions to the State Capitol at a rally Wednesday in Little Rock.
A cross-section of Arkansans launched the letter-writing campaign and petition drive last month in response to overwhelming new scientific evidence showing that Damien Echols, Jessie Misskelley and Jason Baldwin did not commit the 1993 West Memphis murders. That evidence – which includes substantial DNA testing, analysis on other evidence from the nation’s leading forensic science experts, and affidavits from several witnesses and experts – was included in an over 700-page federal court filing in late October on behalf of Echols, who has been on death row for more than 13 years.
“Arkansans of all ages, races and political affiliations, and from every part of the state, have written letters urging the Governor and Attorney General to review this evidence carefully and help overturn these wrongful convictions. The science clearly shows that these three men are innocent, and now the citizens of this state are clearly telling our elected officials that we want them to respect the evidence,” said Capi Peck, a small business owner in Little Rock who is coordinating the campaign.
Community leaders and concerned citizens will gather at 11 a.m. Wednesday morning at the Arkansas Vietnam Veterans Memorial and unfurl a large banner with thousands of postcards from people around the world who support the West Memphis Three. At noon, they will arrive at the front steps of the State Capitol for a rally urging Governor Mike Beeebe and Attorney General Dustin McDaniel to help overturn the convictions. After the rally, hundreds of letters and petitions will be delivered to Beebee’s office. Dixie Chicks lead singer Natalie Maines will speak at the rally, engage in a brief Q&A and help deliver the letters and petitions to Beebe.
“I am humbled and honored to join thousands of Arkansans from all walks of life who have come together in support of justice and fairness,” Maines said. “These men were convicted based on fear and innuendo, but they will be freed based on science and evidence. "I hope elected officials will listen to the community and follow the evidence, and Wednesday’s rally will deliver that message loud and clear.”
Organizers said the Arkansas Take Action campaign puts a formal structure onto a community movement that has been building over the last couple of months, since new evidence in the case began to emerge. “The more ordinary Arkansans hear about the new evidence in this case, the more outraged they are – and the more committed they are to do something about it. This campaign grew out of conversations we’ve all been having in our own living rooms, shops and restaurants over the last several weeks,” Peck said.
Nearly 2,000 people wrote letters or signed petitions in the first three weeks of the campaign. Following are brief excerpts from a few of the letters:
"I am a 56-year-old professor of English who has taught at UALR for the past 27 years and raised my children in this state, and I do not make a habit of getting involved in "causes" or "movements." However, I believe a terrible injustice has occurred in our state, one that has not only damaged our state's reputation but also deprived three young men of their freedom."
David from Little Rock, Arkansas
"Having served my country in Iraq, having fought to bring justice in a foreign land, I am shocked at the injustice that surrounds the case of the West Memphis Three."
Troy from Cincinnati, Ohio
"Please do what prosecutors did not bother to do in the first place: follow the evidence. Please show the world that Arkansas is not a joke, and that we do know how to do what's right. Please, show some courage and insight. At the very least, please insist upon a new trial."
Marck from Little Rock, Arkansas
"With DNA evidence exonerating more and more falsely convicted prisoners each day, you have even more of a reason to grant these men the benefit of such research in their case. Please let the scientific facts already present in their dockets be examined and speak for themselves. Our justice system owes it to them to listen to the expert witnesses who have examined the case."
Megan from Seattle, Washington
Logistical details for Wednesday’s rally at the State Capitol
What: Rally to urge Governor Beebe and Attorney General McDaniel to support efforts the free the West Memphis Three (followed by delivery of hundreds of letters and petitions). Naltalie Maines will do a brief Q&A with reporters.
Who: Arkansas Take Action campaign leaders;
Natalie Maines, lead singer of the Dixie Chicks; will hold brief press conference
Community supporters.
Where: Supporters will gather at the Arkansas Vietnam Veterans Memorial on the Southwest corner lawn in front of the State Capitol;
Rally will be on the front steps of the State Capitol.
When: Wednesday, December 19, 2007;
Supporters will gather by 11:00; rally begins at 12 noon.
Contact: Alice Leeds, 212-874-0675; 917-523-5029
About the West Memphis Three case and the new evidence
On October 30, a 500-page writ was filed in federal court in Little Rock by Echols’ attorneys. It included overwhelming new evidence that Echols is innocent. (While the filing pertains only to the case of Echols, who is on death row, it also shows that Misskelley and Baldwin were wrongfully convicted.) The filing included DNA test results on dozens of pieces of evidence in the case – which showed no link to the three men who were convicted, but did implicated Terry Hobbs, the stepfather of one of the victims. The filing also included in-depth analysis from some of the nation’s leading forensic experts, showing that wounds on one of the victims was caused by animal bites after the murders (not from knives, as the prosecution had contended). Affidavits from several witnesses and experts in the filing contradict every piece of evidence that was used to convict the three men.
Three eight-year-old boys were found dead in a drainage ditch in Robin Hood Hills, a local wooded area near their homes, on May 6, 1993. Less than a month later, 17-year-old Jesse Misskelley “confessed” to the crime and claimed that Echols and Jason Baldwin sexually abused and beat the victims. Police asked Miskelley, a minor with an IQ of 72, to come to the station to “help” with the case, and his interrogation was unconstitutional. Many of the details of his confession (including the time of day the crimes were committed) did not match the facts of the crime. Misskelley was tried and convicted of one count of first-degree murder and two counts of second-degree murder in February 1994. Baldwin and Echols were tried together after Misskelley’s trial, and they were convicted of three counts of murder in March 1994. The following day, Echols was sentenced to die, and he has been on death row ever since. Baldwin and Misskelley are serving life sentences. Since 1995, each of the three has filed a series of appeals on several grounds.
Note to Editors and Producers: For more information or to set up interviews, please contact Alice Leeds, 212-874-0675, aleeds@nyc.rr.com
Alice Whitman Leeds
Public Relations in the Public Interest
52 Riverside Drive, 8-C
New York, NY 10024
Ph: 212-874-0675
Mobile: 917-523-5029
aleeds@nyc.rr.com
Community leaders, supporters and Dixie Chicks’ Natalie Maines will speak and deliver hundreds of letters and petitions asking elected officials to review the overwhelming evidence of innocence and help secure justice
(LITTLE ROCK, AR; December 17, 2007) – In an unprecedented statement of community support for the men who were wrongfully convicted of murdering three West Memphis boys in 1993, local leaders and community members will deliver hundreds of letters and petitions to the State Capitol at a rally Wednesday in Little Rock.
A cross-section of Arkansans launched the letter-writing campaign and petition drive last month in response to overwhelming new scientific evidence showing that Damien Echols, Jessie Misskelley and Jason Baldwin did not commit the 1993 West Memphis murders. That evidence – which includes substantial DNA testing, analysis on other evidence from the nation’s leading forensic science experts, and affidavits from several witnesses and experts – was included in an over 700-page federal court filing in late October on behalf of Echols, who has been on death row for more than 13 years.
“Arkansans of all ages, races and political affiliations, and from every part of the state, have written letters urging the Governor and Attorney General to review this evidence carefully and help overturn these wrongful convictions. The science clearly shows that these three men are innocent, and now the citizens of this state are clearly telling our elected officials that we want them to respect the evidence,” said Capi Peck, a small business owner in Little Rock who is coordinating the campaign.
Community leaders and concerned citizens will gather at 11 a.m. Wednesday morning at the Arkansas Vietnam Veterans Memorial and unfurl a large banner with thousands of postcards from people around the world who support the West Memphis Three. At noon, they will arrive at the front steps of the State Capitol for a rally urging Governor Mike Beeebe and Attorney General Dustin McDaniel to help overturn the convictions. After the rally, hundreds of letters and petitions will be delivered to Beebee’s office. Dixie Chicks lead singer Natalie Maines will speak at the rally, engage in a brief Q&A and help deliver the letters and petitions to Beebe.
“I am humbled and honored to join thousands of Arkansans from all walks of life who have come together in support of justice and fairness,” Maines said. “These men were convicted based on fear and innuendo, but they will be freed based on science and evidence. "I hope elected officials will listen to the community and follow the evidence, and Wednesday’s rally will deliver that message loud and clear.”
Organizers said the Arkansas Take Action campaign puts a formal structure onto a community movement that has been building over the last couple of months, since new evidence in the case began to emerge. “The more ordinary Arkansans hear about the new evidence in this case, the more outraged they are – and the more committed they are to do something about it. This campaign grew out of conversations we’ve all been having in our own living rooms, shops and restaurants over the last several weeks,” Peck said.
Nearly 2,000 people wrote letters or signed petitions in the first three weeks of the campaign. Following are brief excerpts from a few of the letters:
"I am a 56-year-old professor of English who has taught at UALR for the past 27 years and raised my children in this state, and I do not make a habit of getting involved in "causes" or "movements." However, I believe a terrible injustice has occurred in our state, one that has not only damaged our state's reputation but also deprived three young men of their freedom."
David from Little Rock, Arkansas
"Having served my country in Iraq, having fought to bring justice in a foreign land, I am shocked at the injustice that surrounds the case of the West Memphis Three."
Troy from Cincinnati, Ohio
"Please do what prosecutors did not bother to do in the first place: follow the evidence. Please show the world that Arkansas is not a joke, and that we do know how to do what's right. Please, show some courage and insight. At the very least, please insist upon a new trial."
Marck from Little Rock, Arkansas
"With DNA evidence exonerating more and more falsely convicted prisoners each day, you have even more of a reason to grant these men the benefit of such research in their case. Please let the scientific facts already present in their dockets be examined and speak for themselves. Our justice system owes it to them to listen to the expert witnesses who have examined the case."
Megan from Seattle, Washington
Logistical details for Wednesday’s rally at the State Capitol
What: Rally to urge Governor Beebe and Attorney General McDaniel to support efforts the free the West Memphis Three (followed by delivery of hundreds of letters and petitions). Naltalie Maines will do a brief Q&A with reporters.
Who: Arkansas Take Action campaign leaders;
Natalie Maines, lead singer of the Dixie Chicks; will hold brief press conference
Community supporters.
Where: Supporters will gather at the Arkansas Vietnam Veterans Memorial on the Southwest corner lawn in front of the State Capitol;
Rally will be on the front steps of the State Capitol.
When: Wednesday, December 19, 2007;
Supporters will gather by 11:00; rally begins at 12 noon.
Contact: Alice Leeds, 212-874-0675; 917-523-5029
About the West Memphis Three case and the new evidence
On October 30, a 500-page writ was filed in federal court in Little Rock by Echols’ attorneys. It included overwhelming new evidence that Echols is innocent. (While the filing pertains only to the case of Echols, who is on death row, it also shows that Misskelley and Baldwin were wrongfully convicted.) The filing included DNA test results on dozens of pieces of evidence in the case – which showed no link to the three men who were convicted, but did implicated Terry Hobbs, the stepfather of one of the victims. The filing also included in-depth analysis from some of the nation’s leading forensic experts, showing that wounds on one of the victims was caused by animal bites after the murders (not from knives, as the prosecution had contended). Affidavits from several witnesses and experts in the filing contradict every piece of evidence that was used to convict the three men.
Three eight-year-old boys were found dead in a drainage ditch in Robin Hood Hills, a local wooded area near their homes, on May 6, 1993. Less than a month later, 17-year-old Jesse Misskelley “confessed” to the crime and claimed that Echols and Jason Baldwin sexually abused and beat the victims. Police asked Miskelley, a minor with an IQ of 72, to come to the station to “help” with the case, and his interrogation was unconstitutional. Many of the details of his confession (including the time of day the crimes were committed) did not match the facts of the crime. Misskelley was tried and convicted of one count of first-degree murder and two counts of second-degree murder in February 1994. Baldwin and Echols were tried together after Misskelley’s trial, and they were convicted of three counts of murder in March 1994. The following day, Echols was sentenced to die, and he has been on death row ever since. Baldwin and Misskelley are serving life sentences. Since 1995, each of the three has filed a series of appeals on several grounds.
Note to Editors and Producers: For more information or to set up interviews, please contact Alice Leeds, 212-874-0675, aleeds@nyc.rr.com
Alice Whitman Leeds
Public Relations in the Public Interest
52 Riverside Drive, 8-C
New York, NY 10024
Ph: 212-874-0675
Mobile: 917-523-5029
aleeds@nyc.rr.com
John Brummet: That West Memphis case again
Look for a flurry of activity in the next few days from people supporting Damien Echols and those two other men from West Memphis who got sent to prison 14 years ago in part for being very weird, very eerie teenagers.
Most likely, though, this will remain for now a criminal justice matter insulated from any exercise of media and politics. There probably will be a costly and time-consuming legal process before Echols and the others might get freed.
But I predict their release, maybe full exoneration, even if not for years.
It is always possible, I guess, that Echols, Jason Baldwin and Jesse Misskelley, clad in black and talking about witchcraft as they wandered around as misfit 18-year-olds, did in fact torture and kill those three little boys in West Memphis in 1993.
It's too uncertain, though.
The prosecution had no physical evidence and relied solely on sometimes imaginative circumstantial evidence. It extracted easy guilty verdicts from juries predisposed by fear and rage.
Now there are new DNA findings, produced by a sophisticated defense team funded by celebrities like Johnny Depp, who have rallied to Echols' cause. This evidence links none of the three men to the slain boys or the crime scene.
Maybe Echols, Baldwin and Misskelley did all that alleged sodomizing, ritualizing and blood-drinking without leaving a shred of physical evidence. The little boys' bodies were found in water; perhaps the DNA was washed away. Logically, though, I must side with the growing chorus deeming this to have been, at the least, an unsupported judgment driven by emotion stirred by the horror of the crime and the outcast oddness of Echols and the two others.
The police described this as the work of a satanic cult. But outcast kids adults, too can fancy themselves as witches without being Satanists.
Misskelley, with a low IQ, gave the police a confession laced with contradictions and errors.
He recanted hours later. But the police and prosecutors were on their way. Juries convicted all three, sentencing two to life in prison and giving Echols, the scariest-looking and scariest-acting, the death penalty.
These new findings by Echols' defense team make a case that those supposed ritualistic mutilations were actually the postmortem work of animals.
People will tell you that this was an uncommonly vexing case. Every new bit of police information would neither prove nor disprove the guilt of the three.
But convictions are supposed to rise beyond a reasonable doubt.
Anyway, things are starting to percolate anew.
From Death Row, Echols was to give a telephone interview Friday to Larry King. It was to be taped for airing Wednesday night on CNN.
That day, supporters who advocate exoneration and release for Echols and the others will rally at the state Capitol. They intend to make a presentation to Gov. Mike Beebe, or at least someone with his office. It will be of a massive banner made up of supportive postcards from around the world, stretching a city block. Natalie Maines, the Dixie Chick who is no stranger to controversy, is to be on hand.
The matter has been sent back to Crittenden County Circuit Court on pleadings either for vacated verdicts or new trials.
But the state law on new post-conviction DNA evidence allows vacated verdicts only if that evidence provides prima facie proof of innocence. In this case, what we've seen so far only makes it seems even more unlikely or at least unproved that the imprisoned men did these crimes. It doesn't prove conclusively or absolutely that they couldn't have.
Beebe is too much the cautious man to free these three until and unless the argument becomes even more compelling. But Beebe also is the kind of man who would do the right thing eventually. I cannot imagine that he would let Echols get put to death. Commuting the death sentence would seem to be the least, the very least, the state ought to do. Then we could argue about whether he and the others ought to be in jail at all.
(John Brummett is a columnist for the Arkansas News Bureau in Little Rock. His e-mail address is jbrummett@arkansasnews.com; his telephone number is (501) 374-0699.)
Most likely, though, this will remain for now a criminal justice matter insulated from any exercise of media and politics. There probably will be a costly and time-consuming legal process before Echols and the others might get freed.
But I predict their release, maybe full exoneration, even if not for years.
It is always possible, I guess, that Echols, Jason Baldwin and Jesse Misskelley, clad in black and talking about witchcraft as they wandered around as misfit 18-year-olds, did in fact torture and kill those three little boys in West Memphis in 1993.
It's too uncertain, though.
The prosecution had no physical evidence and relied solely on sometimes imaginative circumstantial evidence. It extracted easy guilty verdicts from juries predisposed by fear and rage.
Now there are new DNA findings, produced by a sophisticated defense team funded by celebrities like Johnny Depp, who have rallied to Echols' cause. This evidence links none of the three men to the slain boys or the crime scene.
Maybe Echols, Baldwin and Misskelley did all that alleged sodomizing, ritualizing and blood-drinking without leaving a shred of physical evidence. The little boys' bodies were found in water; perhaps the DNA was washed away. Logically, though, I must side with the growing chorus deeming this to have been, at the least, an unsupported judgment driven by emotion stirred by the horror of the crime and the outcast oddness of Echols and the two others.
The police described this as the work of a satanic cult. But outcast kids adults, too can fancy themselves as witches without being Satanists.
Misskelley, with a low IQ, gave the police a confession laced with contradictions and errors.
He recanted hours later. But the police and prosecutors were on their way. Juries convicted all three, sentencing two to life in prison and giving Echols, the scariest-looking and scariest-acting, the death penalty.
These new findings by Echols' defense team make a case that those supposed ritualistic mutilations were actually the postmortem work of animals.
People will tell you that this was an uncommonly vexing case. Every new bit of police information would neither prove nor disprove the guilt of the three.
But convictions are supposed to rise beyond a reasonable doubt.
Anyway, things are starting to percolate anew.
From Death Row, Echols was to give a telephone interview Friday to Larry King. It was to be taped for airing Wednesday night on CNN.
That day, supporters who advocate exoneration and release for Echols and the others will rally at the state Capitol. They intend to make a presentation to Gov. Mike Beebe, or at least someone with his office. It will be of a massive banner made up of supportive postcards from around the world, stretching a city block. Natalie Maines, the Dixie Chick who is no stranger to controversy, is to be on hand.
The matter has been sent back to Crittenden County Circuit Court on pleadings either for vacated verdicts or new trials.
But the state law on new post-conviction DNA evidence allows vacated verdicts only if that evidence provides prima facie proof of innocence. In this case, what we've seen so far only makes it seems even more unlikely or at least unproved that the imprisoned men did these crimes. It doesn't prove conclusively or absolutely that they couldn't have.
Beebe is too much the cautious man to free these three until and unless the argument becomes even more compelling. But Beebe also is the kind of man who would do the right thing eventually. I cannot imagine that he would let Echols get put to death. Commuting the death sentence would seem to be the least, the very least, the state ought to do. Then we could argue about whether he and the others ought to be in jail at all.
(John Brummett is a columnist for the Arkansas News Bureau in Little Rock. His e-mail address is jbrummett@arkansasnews.com; his telephone number is (501) 374-0699.)
Thursday, December 13, 2007
Attorney General McDaniel Regarding WM3 case!
Attorney General McDaniel regarding WM3 case
Also Thursday, McDaniel said he was stung by criticism his office and the state have not acted quickly enough to address new DNA evidence in the 1993 case in which three teenagers were convicted of slaying three West Memphis second-graders.
DNA tests not available in 1993 are a matter for the courts, and a federal judge has said so by ordering a new hearing, the attorney general said.
"We have three dead children and three older children convicted as adults," McDaniel said. "Anybody who doesn't give weight to the destruction of six boys' lives shouldn't be in public office."
.......
The attorney general also brought up the case of the so-called "West Memphis Three" during his remarks. All three teens were convicted of capital murder in the deaths of Steve Branch, Christopher Byers and Michael Moore. Two of the teens were sentenced to life in prison and a third, Damien Echols, was sentenced to death.
The case is headed for a new hearing in state courts after a federal judge in Little Rock ruled in November attorneys for Echols have not exhausted all state appeals. Echols' lawyers say new DNA test results would exonerate their client.
Supporters asking for the release of the three defendants have planned a Dec. 19 rally at the state Capitol, during which Dixie Chicks lead singer Natalie Maines is scheduled to appear for the unveiling of a banner of postcards from around the world calling for the release of Echols, Jason Baldwin and Jessie Misskelley.
http://www.nwaonline.net/articles/2007/12/13/news/121407fzwaterqualitysuit.txt
Also Thursday, McDaniel said he was stung by criticism his office and the state have not acted quickly enough to address new DNA evidence in the 1993 case in which three teenagers were convicted of slaying three West Memphis second-graders.
DNA tests not available in 1993 are a matter for the courts, and a federal judge has said so by ordering a new hearing, the attorney general said.
"We have three dead children and three older children convicted as adults," McDaniel said. "Anybody who doesn't give weight to the destruction of six boys' lives shouldn't be in public office."
.......
The attorney general also brought up the case of the so-called "West Memphis Three" during his remarks. All three teens were convicted of capital murder in the deaths of Steve Branch, Christopher Byers and Michael Moore. Two of the teens were sentenced to life in prison and a third, Damien Echols, was sentenced to death.
The case is headed for a new hearing in state courts after a federal judge in Little Rock ruled in November attorneys for Echols have not exhausted all state appeals. Echols' lawyers say new DNA test results would exonerate their client.
Supporters asking for the release of the three defendants have planned a Dec. 19 rally at the state Capitol, during which Dixie Chicks lead singer Natalie Maines is scheduled to appear for the unveiling of a banner of postcards from around the world calling for the release of Echols, Jason Baldwin and Jessie Misskelley.
http://www.nwaonline.net/articles/2007/12/13/news/121407fzwaterqualitysuit.txt
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)